Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Shahidi NewsShahidi News
    Subscribe
    • Home
    • Security
    • Courts
    • Governance
    • Features
    • Opinion
    • Technology
    • World
    • Video
    • CJAK
    • Contact Us
    Shahidi NewsShahidi News
    ×
    To place your advert here, kindly call +254115512797 now to get the best rate!
    Home»Courts»‘Crippling Blow’: Inside The Court Of Appeal Ruling On BBI And What It Means
    Courts

    ‘Crippling Blow’: Inside The Court Of Appeal Ruling On BBI And What It Means

    Shahidi News TeamBy Shahidi News TeamAugust 20, 2021Updated:August 21, 20217 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Telegram Email
    court of appeal
    Court of Appeal Justices. Photo/Courtesy.
    Share
    Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Telegram
    Views: 75

    NAIROBI, Kenya, Aug 20 – The Court of Appeal on Friday upheld the judgment of the High Court which declared the Constitution of Kenya amendment bill 2020 popularly referred to as the Building Bridges Initiative (BBI) as irregular, illegal and unconstitutional.

    The bill which sought to institute fundamental changes to the country’s constitution saw the president of the appellate court, Justice Daniel Musinga in part while issuing his orders also say, “the constitution of Kenya amendment Bill 2020 is unconstitutional and a usurpation of the people’s exercise of sovereign power.”

    Road To The ‘Handshake’

    On March 9, 2018, the country was shocked following unexpected events that saw President Uhuru Kenyatta and his the political nemesis ODM leader Raila Odinga at the footsteps of Harambee House in Nairobi partake in a symbolic handshake, while pledging to cease all hostilities as they set a new course that would usher in a new dispensation.

    The results of the surprising turn of events that caught off-guard both proponents’ closest allies went on to birth what we identified as the Bridges Initiative (BBI) after the contentious 2017 elections.

    On Friday, at the corridors of justice, the journey spanning almost three years came to an abrupt halt following concerted efforts and a legal onslaught that sought to correct what critics considered an abuse of power…ultimately stopping the infamous ‘reggae’ movement.

    The seven Judge bench consisting of Justice Daniel Musinga, Fatuma Sichale, Gatembu Kairu, Hannah Okwengu, Roselyn Nambuye, Patrick Kiage and Francis Tuiyott of the appellate court made the consequential judgement.

    BBI is Unconstitutional

    While issuing the orders, Justice Musinga revealed that a majority of the justices were in accord that the basic structure doctrine is applicable in Kenya and that it limits the amendment power set out in Articles 255 – 257 of the Constitution.

    “The basic structure of the Constitution can only be altered through the Primary Constituent Power which must include four sequential processes namely: civic education; public participation and collation of views; Constituent Assembly debate; and ultimately, a referendum,” said Justice Musinga.

    The court further ruled that president Kenyatta does not have authority under the Constitution to initiate changes to the Constitution.

    As a result, the declared that a constitutional amendment can only be initiated by Parliament through a Parliamentary initiative under Article 256 or through a popular initiative under Article 257 of the Constitution.

    Critics of the bill said the presidents’ attempts were akin to delegating himself the roles of the proponent and even the referee, which would give them an unfair advantage in determining the outcome of the process.

    Furthermore, Justice Musinga said county assemblies and Parliament, “cannot, as part of their constitutional mandate, change the contents of the Constitution of Kenya Amendment Bill, 2020 initiated through a popular initiative under Article 257 of the Constitution.”

    The court however set aside the order of the High Court that President Kenyatta contravened Chapter 6 of the Constitution, and specifically Article 73(1)(a)(i), by initiating and promoting a constitutional change process contrary to the provisions of the Constitution on amendment of the Constitution but ruled civil proceedings may be instituted against him.

    “Civil Court proceedings can be instituted against the President or a person performing the functions of the office of President during their tenure of office in respect of anything done or not done contrary to the Constitution,” he said.

    Though the Steering Committee on the Implementation of the Building Bridges to a United Kenya Taskforce Report (The BBI Steering Committee) was said to lack the legal capacity to initiate any action towards promoting constitutional changes , the appeal court set aside orders by the High Court that its establishment by president vide a Gazette notice was unconstitutional and as such an unlawful entity.

    The collection of endorsement signatures was also described as flawed by a majority of the justices who pointed out to a lack of proper legislation governing the exercise which included, the collection of signatures, presentation and verification.

    “There was neither an adequate legal or regulatory framework to govern the conduct of referenda,” reads a section of the Judgement.

    Musinga ruled that IEBC had contravened its administrative procedures during the verification of signatures, declaring it illegal, null and void because it lacked the requisite quorum. As a result, the electoral body was found to be in violation of Sections 5, 6 and 11 of the Statutory Instruments Act, 2013.

    The High Court in its ruling had initially faulted the proponents of the bill saying attempts to create an additional 70 constituencies was tantamount to, “establishing a new form of government” contrary to that in the current constitution.

    The Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission Chairman Wafula Chebukati had in the past termed the move to determine the establishment of constituencies as the sole mandate of the electoral body and not politician.

    “The second schedule to the Constitution of Kenya (Amendment) Bill, 2020 in so far as it purports to: predetermine the allocation of the proposed additional seventy constituencies, and to direct the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission on its function of constituency delimitation, is unconstitutional,” he said.

    Government of President Uhuru Kenyatta may have so far captured Law Society of Kenya but has lost Kenya. We have succeeded in defending the Constitution against a coordinated assault by him and Former Prime Minister Raila Odinga. Their actions continue being null and void. ^POLSK

    — Nelson Havi (@NelsonHavi) August 20, 2021

    IEBC was directed to desist from undertaking any processes required under Article 257(4) and (5) in respect of the Constitution of Kenya (Amendment) Bill, 2020.

    Political Leaders React to Judgment

    Various leaders took to social media to react to the ruling including former Prime Minister Raila Odinga who said, “we have to move on.

    Odinga added that the decision of the court of appeal is “remarkable as it forms part of the continuing conversation on the future of Kenya and the significance of the new constitution to the nation’s political culture.”

    He further said that the ruling did not signal and end of the ‘conversation’ saying parties involved will make a decision on how to proceed based on the ruling.

    “This is not an indication of our regard to this noble initiative, far from that, we feel that e must now see the first for the trees and pursue the bigger goal of setting the issues facing this country right.” the Orange Democratic Movement leader said in a statement.

    It is likely that today's Court of Appeal ruling is not the end of the conversation and the parties involved will each make their own decisions on how to proceed from the decision that has been delivered today.

    But we feel that we have to move on. pic.twitter.com/hMl5pf0vtq

    — Raila Odinga (@RailaOdinga) August 20, 2021

    The longtime opposition leader recently launched what many perceived to be his presidential bid by unveiling his national unity plan dubbed, ‘Azimio La Umoja’.

    Meanwhile Deputy President William Ruto appeared ecstatic in a tweet saying “God came through for Kenya.”

    “Our God,help the alliance of the unknown, the jobless,the Hustlers & struggling farmers to now engineer our economy from bottom-up,” the Deputy President said.

    Ruto is on record criticizing the BBI initiative. He had termed it as a ploy of a few to ‘divide’ government jobs amongst themselves.

    GOD,our heavenly FATHER has come THROUGH for Kenya & STOPPED the COALITION of the known, the mighty, & the powerful from destroying our CONSTITUTION.Our GOD,help the ALLIANCE of the unknown, the jobless,the Hustlers & struggling farmers to now ENGINEER our ECONOMY from BOTTOM UP. pic.twitter.com/R0mDihQaa6

    — William Samoei Ruto, PhD (@WilliamsRuto) August 20, 2021

    Following the Judgement, Amani National Congress (ANC) leader Musalia Mudavadi said the spirit of the Constitution, “is bigger than all of us,”

    “We vested the power to interpret it in the courts. The judges have pronounced themselves, let us respect the judgment & focus on the revival of the economy as we foster National Cohesion,” Mudavadi, who is among leaders seeking the country’s presidency next year said.

    The spirit of the Constitution is bigger than all of us. We vested the power to interpret it in the courts. The judges have pronounced themselves, let us respect the judgment & focus on the revival of the economy as we foster National Cohesion.https://t.co/ialT0jm2mI#BBIRuling pic.twitter.com/iWfiWlxkMF

    — Musalia W Mudavadi (@MusaliaMudavadi) August 20, 2021

    Wiper party leader Kalonzo Musyoka called on all parties involved to respect the Court of Appeal’s decision and set their sights on nation building.

    Statement on the Court of Appeal Decision. pic.twitter.com/ZaKBqHFlwB

    — Kalonzo Musyoka (@skmusyoka) August 20, 2021

    “Today the court of appeal has delivered its judgment, no nation can exist outside the rue of law and no constitution can exist without constitutionalism. There is no loser in this process. A stronger democracy, a greater Kenya,” the former Vice President said.

    Want to send us a story? Contact Shahidi News Tel: +254115512797 (Mobile & WhatsApp)

    Share. Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Telegram
    Shahidi News Team
    • Website

    Telling Crime, Security, Governance, Human Rights, and Investigative Stories. An initiative by CJAK. Contact Shahidi News Tel: +254115512797 (Mobile & WhatsApp)

    Related Posts

    Youth Groups Take the Lead in Kisumu’s Economic Empowerment Drive

    April 20, 2025

    Senior Superintendent of Police Jared Ojuok Elected President of the International Police Association Kenya Section

    March 11, 2025

    Impeached DP Gachagua Skips DCI Summons Over Assassination Claims

    October 23, 2024

    Ex-Police Spokesperson Charles Owino Appointed Head of National Communications Centre

    October 6, 2024
    Add A Comment

    Comments are closed.

    An initiative by CJAK
    Banner Ad
    Latest updates
    Latest News

    DR Congo Bans Kabila’s Party Over Alleged Rebel Ties as Tensions Escalate in Goma

    By Brian ObuyaApril 20, 2025Updated:April 20, 20254 Mins Read

    The Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) has suspended the political party of former President Joseph…

    Crime

    Youth Groups Take the Lead in Kisumu’s Economic Empowerment Drive

    By Shahidi News TeamApril 20, 20252 Mins Read

    Youth and women groups across Kisumu County are taking the lead in reshaping their communities,…

    Latest News

    Former NTV Reporter Silas Apollo is dead

    By Brian ObuyaApril 13, 20253 Mins Read

    Silas Apollo, a former NTV journalist who was working with Nairobi Law Monthly at the…

    BREAKING NEWS

    WANTED: Police Launch Manhunt for Tana River Lands Chief Over Bribery, Abuse of Office

    By ContributorApril 12, 20252 Mins Read

    Tana River County’s Lands and Urban Planning Chief Officer, Francis Malibe,is said to have bolted…

    An initiative by CJAK
    Banner Ad

    Telling Crime, Security, Governance, Human Rights, and Investigative Stories. An initiative by CJAK.

    For Business Partnerships, Press Releases, Media Invites and General Inquiries; Contact: Editor, Shahidi News Tel: +254115512797

    Latest Posts

    DR Congo Bans Kabila’s Party Over Alleged Rebel Ties as Tensions Escalate in Goma

    April 20, 2025

    Youth Groups Take the Lead in Kisumu’s Economic Empowerment Drive

    April 20, 2025

    Former NTV Reporter Silas Apollo is dead

    April 13, 2025
    sitemap
    • Home
    • Security
    • Courts
    • Governance
    • Features
    • Opinion
    • Technology
    • World
    • Video
    • CJAK
    • Contact Us
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram WhatsApp Telegram
    © 2025 Shahidi News. Designed by Okii.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.